| Once-hyped
fuel cells are just getting started
The buzz quieted more than a decade
ago. But John Sheridan, president, chief executive and director of Ballard
Power Systems, remembers it fondly - and ironically.
Ballard, born in 1979 as Ballard
Research and now headquartered in Burnaby near Vancouver, B.C., had developed
a technology destined to change the world. It was a hydrogen fuel cell
with a proton-exchange membrane. In practical application, it would trigger
a reaction between hydrogen and oxygen to create electricity.
In cars and trucks, hydrogen fuel
cells would mean an end to tailpipe pollution as we've come to know and
hate it. It would mean less dependence on foreign oil. It would remove
the automobile as a negative component in the environmental equation.
And there was so much more. The hydrogen
fuel cell technology that powered cars and trucks could also be used to
power homes and buildings, conceivably removing them from traditional electrical
power grids.
It was all very wonderful. The media
were agog. Politicians were enthralled. Wall Street types were aroused.
Institutional environmentalists - people who take the "right" environmental
stance as much for the acquisition of political power as they do for altruism
- were at least interested.>
---ADVERTISEMENT---
Sheridan, interviewed in his glass-enclosed
office in Burnaby, smiled and shook his head. "For the most part, we had
only a working proof-of-concept back then," he said. "We hadn't really
begun to do anything with it. But everybody was excited about it."
Between 1989 and 1994 Ballard, hydrogen
fuel cells and car companies such as General Motors that had begun investing
heavily in fuel cell technology were all over the news.
But there were inherent problems
that would curtail a fickle public's interest. Fuel cell technology is
science, and science often does not conform to the needs of the next news
cycle. There are trials and errors. Science has little respect for deadlines.
And science is complicated and expensive.
Its complexity defies the sound bite, whether political or straight news.
It turns off a public that finds the voting intrigue of American Idol substantially
more interesting than proton-exchange membranes. Its expense rattles investors
who are more interested in the next big payoff than they are in the next
big or best thing.
So, Ballard and hydrogen fuel cells
faded from the news, ceded to the appeal of gas-electric hybrid technology
and to the illusions of the silver bullet and the quick fix. And therein
resides the irony.
Neither Ballard nor hydrogen fuel
cells went away. In fact, they are bigger than ever, as evidenced by Ballard's
sprawling research-and-development and manufacturing facility in Burnaby
and the importance of the technology to countries such as Japan.
"Maybe we made some mistakes in the
beginning by over-promising - that is, giving people the idea that the
benefits of this technology would be immediate," Sheridan conceded. "The
reality is that we're in a marathon race," he said, suggesting that Ballard
and the technology it has pioneered has many more miles to run before it
reaches any finish line.
At the moment, despite its reported
loss of $14.2 million in the first quarter, Ballard's future looks promising.
Research and development continues apace on the development of smaller,
relatively lightweight, more powerful fuel cells for cars and trucks. Every
major automobile company, including Toyota, is investing heavily in the
development of fuel cells for future commercial automotive applications,
some of which could enter the market as early as 2010.
Japan, through its various energy
companies and in cooperation with Ballard its competitors, rapidly is increasing
the number of fuel-cell power units installed in buildings. The technology,
largely government-subsidized, is so popular in Japan that the country's
energy companies are beginning to run fuel-cell advertisements on TV.
And fuel cells are beginning to show
up in sectors largely invisible to the media and the public. A fuel-cell
powered forklift, anyone? They are beginning to be used in factories and
other materials-handling businesses worldwide.
Also, the next time a storm or other
disaster short-circuits the grid power going to your local cellphone tower,
fuel-cell backup power could keep you connected thanks to unhappy lessons
learned during disasters such as Hurricane Katrina in 2005.
Traditional lead-acid battery backup
devices ran out of juice several hours after the storm, disrupting first-responder
communications as well as communications among families and friends. Now,
many telecommunication companies are saying that hydrogen-powered fuel
cells would have kept those cellphone towers working longer and more reliably.
But, as Sheridan said, continued
development and application of the technology amounts to a long-distance
race. But at least he and Ballard now appear to be gaining more political
backing in that endeavor from provincial and state governments in Canada
and the United States, as evidenced by Ballard's prominent role last week
at the Pacific Economic Summit's Clean Energy Conference.
Both Gordon Campbell, premier of
British Columbia, and California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger cited Ballard
for its contributions to the development of alternative energy. But perhaps
the most useful comments came from Campbell, who urged governments and
environmental groups to abandon the silliness of pitting one technology
against another.
"We have to embrace the changes in
front of us," Campbell said. "We have to look at what is being offered
and ask: 'How do we make the world a better place?' "
That means we have to be willing
to develop technologies that might not have an instant impact, "but that
will have an impact 20 or 30 years from now, that will have an impact on
our children and grandchildren," Campbell said.
That requires three things all too
often missing from political and media landscapes: vision, patience and
selflessness.
------ End of article
|