| SANTA MONICA,
Calif. -- Like millions of other motorists who battle daily traffic
on California's congested roadways, Gary Welling always keeps a nervous
eye on his fuel gauge.
As the needle dips towards empty,
Welling faces a familiar dilemma -- drive a few more kilometres and risk
becoming stranded roadside, or find a place to fill up.
"If it's half full, I fill it up,"
says Welling, a water resources manager with the city of Santa Monica.
His abundant caution is well justified,
since the city-owned car he's driving is a hydrogen-powered Toyota Prius,
and the only local service station is tucked away down a dead-end side-street
off Interstate 405.
"You only get 35 to 40 miles (56
to 64 kilometres) per tank with this car," says Welling, "so you've really
got to stay close to the fuelling stations."
For all the hassle, Welling isn't
complaining. If anything, he feels he's part of history in the making.
The Santa Monica hydrogen station
is an early outpost on a vast "hydrogen highway" that Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger
hopes will eventually spread from southern California to the Canadian Rockies.
The idea is like something from one
of Schwarzenegger's futuristic movies -- a string of refuelling stations
where enviro-conscious motorists can fill their zero-emission hydrogen
cars on coastline trips from Baja to Whistler.
"People are not going to buy fuel
cell vehicles if there is not a place to fill up," says Dan Skopec, undersecretary
of the California Environmental Protection Agency. "The governor is committed
to help build a hydrogen highway in California and he wants to work with
other states and provinces to do the same."
America's greenest governor will
promote the ambitious plan next week during a three-day Canadian tour that
will take him to Ottawa, Toronto and Vancouver.
Already, Schwarzenegger has found
willing partners in British Columbia. Premier Gordon Campbell is forging
ahead with plans to build an $89-million "hydrogen highway" that will stretch
between Vancouver and Whistler in time for the 2010 Winter Olympics. Last
month, he announced the province would use $45 million in federal funding
to begin building 20 hydrogen-fuelled buses and the province's first fuelling
stations.
Campbell and Schwarzenegger agreed
in March to eventually link the two systems through the states of Washington
and Oregon.
"I think what this hydrogen highway
does is create a totally benign means of transportation in terms of emissions,"
Campbell said in an interview.
Hydrogen has long been touted as
a clean alternative to gasoline because its only emissions are small amounts
of water vapour.
And, indeed, most major car companies
have prototype hydrogen fuel cell cars in development. Honda recently loaned
its latest-generation fuel cell vehicle, the FCX, to a Hollywood actress
for everyday use. General Motors will be releasing 100 of its Equinox fuel
cell vehicles for market tests this spring.
Still, many experts doubt any of
the vehicles - which still cost hundreds of thousands of dollars to produce
- will hit sales lots for at least another ddecade.
For one thing, the technology has
yet to catch up with the dream.
A key technical hurdle is fuel storage,
because hydrogen-powered cars require extraordinarily large tanks to hold
the same amount of energy as a regular gasoline-powered car. As a result,
most hydrogen fuel cell prototypes have a maximum range of 160 to 250 kilometres
on a fill-up, a major inconvenience when refuelling stations are scarce.
The test cars used by cities like Santa Monica - which are powered by an
internal-combustion engine retrofitted to run on hydrogen fuel - have a
maximum range of about 70 kilometres.
The short range of today's hydrogen
cars has forced Schwarzenegger to alter his original plan to fund hydrogen
stations along California's major freeway. Instead, they are clustered
around major urban centres for the convenience of municipal fleets.
"Although they work really well in
these urban settings, they are not really ready to go between Sacramento
and L.A.," says Gerhard Achtelik, manager of zero-emission infrastructure
at California's Air Resources Board, a division of the state's environmental
protection agency. "As the appropriate number of cars come out, you can
expect the highway to expand."
In the entire state of California,
however, only two dozen of a planned 250 hydrogen fuelling stations have
so far been built. None, moreover, is open to the general public - which
is just as well, since there are no hydrogen vehicles in private use anywhere
in the state. Of the 170 hydrogen-powered cars and buses on the road, most
are operated either by car companies or city fleets running demonstration
projects.
"It's kind of premature to be deploying
infrastructure for a hydrogen highway, in part because there aren't any
practical cars," says Joseph Romm, a senior fellow at the Center for American
Progress and a former assistant energy secretary in the Clinton administration.
"And I don't expect there will be for quite some time. So driving (hydrogen-fuelled)
cars up and down the West Coast is not something I expect a lot of people
will be doing."
By contrast, Romm notes, there are
180,000 gas stations in the United States.
"One reason why people like their
cars and drive so much is they don't have to worry they will have any trouble
filling up."
Most experts believe the cost of
hydrogen-powered cars will come down as technology improves and mass manufacturing
capabilities are developed. Even so, opinion is divided on whether consumers
will ever warm to hydrogen cars.
Welling, who uses his hydrogen Toyota
Prius for work, says Santa Monica residents regularly ask him when they
can buy one of the cars.
"This town is pretty green, so people
are always coming over and give me the thumbs up," he says.
Others are wary. Rick Sikes, who
manages Santa Monica's fleet of five hydrogen-powered cars, says one employee
refused to drive the vehicle because he feared it was a "million-dollar
bomb."
"I seriously doubt most Americans
will want to drive a car where they are one or two feet from a 5,000 pound-per-square-inch
canister of hydrogen," says Romm, author of Hell or High Water, which examines
the viability of alternative fuels.
Schwarzenegger, however, remains
determined to enforce much tougher greenhouse gas emission standards on
all vehicles. The governor, who helped popularize Hummers by buying one
of the gas-guzzling giants in the 1990s, had General Motors develop a hydrogen-powered
H2 version of the vehicle in 2004. Within the next four years, California
may require major car companies to produce at least 2,500 hydrogen-powered
cars.
"There won't be millions of cars
out tomorrow, but we expect thousands in the near future," says Achtelik.
Companies developing hydrogen technology
are taking pains to make the vehicles and fuelling stations look as much
like regular service stations as possible. The station in Santa Monica,
for instance, has a pump with a digital display that shows volume, price
per kilogram and total cost of a fill up - even though no city employee
pays a dime when filling up.
The hydrogen nozzle fits in the same
place as on a gas-fuelled car. The only difference is a second cable, which
measures pressure in the storage tank and is attached to a receptacle on
the bumper.
"You have to overcome peoples' reluctance
to change by making things familiar," says Sikes. "The biggest problem
that anybody has is plugging in that extra cable."
In British Columbia, the premier
vows the province's fleet of hydrogen buses will be on the road in time
for the Olympics and he's cautiously optimistic about completing a link
of hydrogen stations to California by 2010 as well.
When Canada's first gasoline station
opened in Vancouver 100 years ago, few people believed cars would replace
horses and buggies as the dominant mode of travel, Campbell notes.
"Everyone who points out that we
don't have a mass-produced automobile based on hydrogen is correct, but
it is a technology which has huge potential."
Unofficial Schwarzenegger itinerary:
May 29: Toronto where he may meet
Environment Minister John Baird
May 30: Speaks to Economic Club of
Toronto at midday. Flies to Ottawa for possible meeting with Prime Minister
Stephen Harper and reception at the American Embassy
May 31: keynote speaker of Pacific
Economic Summit in Vancouver.
|