| Some people
call hydrogen America's future fuel. Others think it's ready for the spotlight
today.
The question of how quickly to introduce
the country to hydrogen technology arose at the National Hydrogen Association's
17th annual meeting, held last week in Long Beach, Calif. The 1,100 attendees
included a contingent from Air Products and Chemicals Inc. of Trexlertown,
the world's largest hydrogen supplier.
Hydrogen, an abundant element, can
be used to make low-pollution or pollution-free electricity to power cars,
buildings and more. Backers say hydrogen could help wean America off dirty,
imported fossil fuels — but not for 20 years or more, as scientists tackle
major technical and supply challenges.
Some in the hydrogen field have been
wary of pushing it too far into the public eye. They fear that rushing
the technology into everyday use could backfire.
But utility industry veteran S. David
Freeman used his speech at the association's awards luncheon Tuesday to
try to jostle the industry into faster action.
High oil prices, continued pollution
problems and other factors give hydrogen an immediate opportunity to score
points with America, Freeman said. And, while the fuel is not ready for
a full-scale rollout, some uses — including certain types of hydrogen-powered
cars — are far enough along to be displayed and promoted on a limited basis,
he said.
''I don't understand why we're not
bragging about what we can offer today,'' said Freeman, president of the
Los Angeles Board of Harbor Commissioners. ''I don't understand why there's
a reluctance.''
To some degree, President Bush set
the cautious tone in his 2003 State of the Union address, when he predicted
an American child born that year would grow up to drive a hydrogen car.
Freeman said the industry needs to shoot for more immediate gains, though.
''Saying, 'This is for the grandchildren,'
is not a very good marketing approach,'' he said.
It remains to be seen whether the
industry will take Freeman's advice. Some at the conference said the two
outlooks can be balanced. Steve Ellis, manager of fuel cell marketing for
Honda, compared the situation to a marathon, in which racers run long and
steady but are capable of bursts of speed.
''Let's all maintain a reasonable
pace so we make it to the finish line,'' Ellis said at a Wednesday morning
forum.
The weeklong meeting included one
significant reach out to the public. Some 400 people who were not part
of the conference showed up at a ''ride and drive'' event Tuesday. They
took turns driving nine hydrogen-powered cars over part of the route of
the Toyota Grand Prix of Long Beach auto race.
Many hydrogen-powered cars use fuel
cells, devices that turn hydrogen into electricity using chemical reactions.
Fuel cells' range and reliability cannot yet match those of gasoline engines.
They also use costly precious metals to trigger the reactions, making them
too expensive for routine production.
One recurring theme of the conference
was the increasing use of internal-combustion engines, such as those in
today's cars, converted to run on hydrogen. Those engines are not as clean
as fuel cells. But they are cheaper, more reliable, can be made on the
same assembly lines as gasoline engines, and can serve as a ''bridge''
technology until fuel cells improve.
''I think internal combustion engines
are going to have to play a very important role in the transition to the
ultimate fuel cell vehicle,'' said Venki Raman, an independent industry
consultant from Emmaus.
Freeman, in keeping with his theme,
called for carmakers to increase their production, and promotion, of hydrogen
internal-combustion engines.
''It seems [hydrogen combustion engines]
are almost a military secret. It's all fuel cells, fuel cells, fuel cells,''
he said.
Building a hydrogen fueling network,
a common topic whenever hydrogen researchers gather, also emerged as a
subject of debate — and disagreement.
For hydrogen cars to work on a large
scale, energy companies need to build hydrogen pumping stations. The stations
might make hydrogen on-site, have it piped in from nearby plants, or get
it trucked in by trailers. Regardless of method, the hydrogen network is
expected to cost billions of dollars to build.
The hydrogen network is often framed
as a high-stakes chicken-and-egg scenario. Automakers don't want to build
large numbers of hydrogen cars without fueling stations in place to serve
them. And energy companies don't want to build the stations, which can
cost $1 million each, without enough cars to make them viable.

|