| The battery
of the future, if a Berkeley startup gets its way, looks something like
a fat stick of butter with metal grills stuck on the sides.
And it isn't a battery, not technically
at least. It's a 4-inch-high fuel cell that should last 10 times longer
than the batteries it was designed to replace.
Its inventors, founders of a firm
called H2Volt, have joined the hunt for one of the technology industry's
Holy Grails -- a new power source capable of running the portable electronics
products that grow more complex every year.
As phones shoot pictures and download
songs, as music players keep calendars and sprout video screens, their
thirst for electricity swells. Rechargeable batteries as well as the throwaways
that line supermarket check-out aisles have improved, but not fast enough
to keep up.
Some companies are trying to keep
the battery's basic design while using different chemicals to lengthen
its life. Others, such as H2Volt, envision a future running on micro fuel
cells, which generate power from small amounts of fuel. The hunt has attracted
major tech firms. H2Volt, for instance, is backed by German communications
powerhouse Siemens.
"We're going to go from hours on
a laptop battery to days. Or from days for a cell phone battery to weeks,"
said Farshid Arman, a Siemens director of venture technology who sits on
H2Volt's board. "There's no sense having wireless applications if you need
a wire for energy."
Other companies pursuing their own
cells designs include IBM, Motorola and
NEC.
So far, however, the goal of a cheap
and powerful micro fuel cell has proven elusive. Toshiba, for example,
planned to introduce a fuel cell for laptop computers in 2004. That didn't
happen and the cell's release was delayed, again, this year.
Optimists say the fuel cell business
is about to take off, with one recent study from research firm NanoMarkets
estimating the market to be worth $1.6 billion by 2010. But the products
have been notoriously slow to hit store shelves.
"With micro fuel cells, they're always
two years off," said Rob Enderle, president of the Enderle Group tech industry
analysis firm. "The fact is, we are finally seeing light at the end of
the tunnel. People are building prototypes that seem to work."
There's no lack of competition. More
than 60 companies are working on micro fuel cells that use methanol, according
to a Mountain View company that makes a key piece of such cells. And methanol
isn't the only potential fuel being explored.
"Used to be, we'd see 20-piece orders,"
said James Balcom, chief executive of PolyFuel Inc., which makes thin membranes
used inside fuel cells. "We're now seeing 200-piece orders." A typical
laptop fuel cell, he said, uses about 10.
Although the need has existed for
years, the tech industry's latest incarnation has made it more urgent.
Mobile devices that tie into the Internet, play songs and videos, and oh
yes, make phone calls draw more power with each new function. A largely
glowing review of Apple's new video iPod in the New York Times, for example,
noted that the battery died after two hours of videos.
Rechargeable lithium-ion batteries
have been the standard for most portable electronics. But the need for
more juice has led some companies to tinker with the chemical mix. PowerGenix
in San Diego, for example, has developed a battery using nickel and zinc,
a change the company says allows its battery to be smaller than competitors'
while delivering higher voltage.
Much of the research in the field,
however, centers on micro fuel cells, shrunken versions of the same devices
that some researchers hope will one day power cars.
Whereas rechargeable batteries store
electricity, fuel cells generate it, for as long as their fuel lasts. A
fuel cell uses oxygen and hydrogen in a process that takes electrons from
the hydrogen, sends them through an external circuit to generate power,
and then combines the elements into water.
The difficulty lies in making the
devices small and light enough to work with laptops and phones as well
as cheap enough to mass produce. Many fuel cells, for example, use platinum
as a catalyst -- hardly inexpensive.
Medis Technologies has created a
fuel cell that doesn't use platinum. The New York company plans to start
selling its disposable Power Pack next year and recently hired a company
to build it in a production line capable of cranking out 1.5 million of
the devices per month.
Each Power Pack can fully recharge
a typical cell phone five or six times, according to the company. Or, if
the phone's battery dies, the pack should provide about 20 hours of operation.
Medis plans to sell them to mobile-phone companies for about $8 apiece,
and those companies will then sell them to customers, Chief Executive Officer
Robert Lifton said.
Medis also is developing a version
of the power pack for the military. The recent Gulf Coast hurricanes, which
knocked out electricity across swaths of the South, have demonstrated the
need, Lifton said.
"People have now found out that in
disaster areas, it's highly desirable to have some way of powering your
cell phone," he said.
H2Volt also wants the Pentagon's
business.
The company is working with the U.S.
Navy to develop fuel cells for wireless sensing devices. While most fuel
cells use liquid chemicals, H2Volt's uses dry fuels, which should make
them substantially lighter.
Military sensors probably won't need
fuel cells as small as cell phones would require. Focusing first on the
military, therefore, should give H2Volt income while the company continues
to shrink its product, a strategy the company emphasizes while hitting
up venture capitalists.
"If you go out there and say 'I need
$500 million, and in three years, you're going to have the teeniest battery,'
that's the end of the meeting," said Stefan Heuser, president and chief
executive officer of the Siemens Technology-to-Business Center.
The center, based in Berkeley, seeks
out and funds research on products that Siemens could one day use, typically
spending $300,000 to $800,000 on each project. The center also acts as
a kind of incubator -- giving the companies it backs advice on bringing
their products to market -- and H2Volt operates out of the center's Berkeley
office.
Despite the intense interest in micro
fuel cells, some researchers don't see them supplanting conventional batteries
in the near future.
"It's still a little ways down the
road," said Daniel Doughty, manager of the advanced power source technology
group at Sandia National Laboratories. "For small amounts of power, batteries
are going to be hard to beat."
A fuel cell is, after all, a device
rather than a simple repository for power. It must bring in oxygen and
combine fuels at a measured pace, Doughty said. And the mechanics for doing
so are hard to shrink while still ensuring reliability, he said.
"All these mechanical systems are
difficult when they're miniaturized," Doughty said. "I think these things
will happen, but they'll happen for larger devices before they do for cell
phones."

|