![]() |
| Types of Fuel Cells | The Basics | Fuel Cell News | Basics on Hydrogen | Search| |
|
|
Record of interview:
corporatefile.com.au
Ceramic Fuel Cells Limited has announced
a Letter of Intent (LOI) with the
German energy utility EWE to develop
fuel cell based combined heat and power
(CHP) systems for the residential
market. This follows the June signing of a
contract with EWE for a commercial
field trial of two CHP units. Ceramic Fuel
Cells has already shipped the first
of a number of field trial units to Powerco in
New Zealand in June 2005. What is
the significance of your first commercial
partnership with a European utility?
CEO Brendan Dow
CFU has really entered the world
stage with this deal with EWE. In the last
twelve months CFU has signed four
customers for field trials of our prototype fuel
cell powered micro-CHP electricity
generator. We’ve shipped our first unit and
now also signed an agreement for
ongoing collaboration. Not many fuel cell
companies targeting small scale
stationary electricity generation have achieved
these milestones.
EWE is a significant partner because
it’s so large and it operates in central Europe
and Germany, where the micro-CHP
market is growing rapidly. EWE is
Germany’s fifth largest electricity
and gas utility with a turnover of about €6
billion. It’s been very active in
validating fuel cell powered CHP systems over the
last four to five years and is fully
committed to the deployment of this technology.
We believe that the European market
for fuel cell powered CHP will be very large
and a first step in being able to
access this market has been achieved by signing
this contract with EWE. In the UK
alone, British Gas has predicted micro-CHP
sales could be around 200,000 in
less than five years.
corporatefile.com.au
EWE has been trialing Sulzer-Hexis
and Valliant fuel cells and has operated trial
units in private homes for some
years. Why did EWE seek another supplier?
CEO Brendan Dow
EWE wants to make sure that it’s
evaluating all commercially relevant fuel cell
CHP units. One difference with our
technology is that we can offer a 1:1 heat to
power ratio compared with other
fuel cell technologies that have heat to power
ratios of 2:1 or 3:1. That is, they
produce 2 or 3 times as much heat as power.
Other conventional engine CHP technologies
have even higher ratios, for instance
Stirling engine units are about
6:1. If a CHP unit produces too much heat, it has
to be turned off during summer,
meaning it’s less efficient overall. We’ve
designed our unit so it can be run
as an electrical generator throughout the year
providing year round base load power
without the need to shut down during
summer months.
corporatefile.com.au
What differentiates your CHP units
from those of Sulzer-Hexis and Vaillant?
CEO Brendan Dow
The main difference is the higher
electric efficiency of our unit and thus our low
heat to power ratio. High electric
efficiency means less gas consumption per kW
of power, which means of course
lower gas costs per kW of power, and also less
CO2 emission per kW of power, and
as mentioned earlier, a lower heat to power
ratio which enables longer periods
of operation throughout the year. Naturally,
higher system efficiency delivers
better outcomes - lower costs, extended life of
fuel supplies, and a greater contribution
to reaching targets on greenhouse gas
emissions. Electric efficiency of
CHP systems of more than about 35 percent
enables a CHP unit to produce electricity
more efficiently than that supplied by
conventional and centralised systems
on the electricity grid. This we believe can
provide a significant competitive
advantage.
corporatefile.com.au
When will you supply the units,
and what is the significance of the LOI?
CEO Brendan Dow
We expect to deliver the units in
the last quarter of this calendar year.
The LOI allows us to work closely
with EWE to share an understanding of the key
drivers of CHP technology, develop
field support and installation training
programmes and promote the benefits
and features of fuel cell technology. We’re
confident the relationship with
EWE would have developed strongly through our
field trials, even without this
agreement, but the fact that we’ve both signed this
document gives some framework and
commitment to our relationship, and means
we can collaborate on the ‘big picture’,
in parallel to the field trial.
The LOI specifically sets out how
we’ll work together to determine specifications,
technical standards and opportunities
for commercial market development for fuel
cell systems. This could include
verifying economic and technical models,
environmental benefit analysis and
determining most suitable generator sizes.
We’ll also work closely with the
relevant standards and government agencies in
the German domestic and pan-European
markets.
corporatefile.com.au
Do competitive pressures preclude
you from establishing a similar relationship
with other German energy utilities?
CEO Brendan Dow
At this early stage of entering
the European market, we’re choosing our partners
carefully to maximise the value
of our resources. In the medium term we would
like to have relationships with
other German utilities, ideally all of them, although
the relationship may be an indirect
one through one of our strategic partners.
However in the short term, our immediate
focus is on delivering our field trial
contract and working closely with
EWE.
Our aim is to partner a select number
of utilities and to work closely with them to
develop a fuel cell system that
meets their commercial needs. Not all utilities have
the same high-level strategy or
plan to develop distributed energy generation as
EWE, or fuel cells energy generation
for that matter.
corporatefile.com.au
You have attributed the successful
negotiation of this contract to the establishment
of your European subsidiary. What
other European partnerships are you
pursuing?
CEO Brendan Dow
We recognise the EU market is our
first target market. The Europeans are so
advanced with energy efficient appliances,
distributed energy generation and cogeneration.
They have significant challenges
to meet Kyoto targets whilst
continuing to generate electricity.
An increasing number of utilities are watching
fuel cells to see how different
companies are progressing with their technologies.
Likewise an increasing number of
appliance manufacturers are watching fuel cell
companies to see which systems will
be best for integration into their appliances.
After all, we expect that it’ll be
the appliance manufacturers, not the fuel cell
developers, that will integrate
the fuel cells into domestic appliances, such as
micro-CHP or small generators, for
sale to the broader market and utilities.
We have initiated discussions with
all major UK and German utilities, and EWE
has visited our head office and
factory facilities in Melbourne, Australia. We’ve
also initiated discussions with
some potential Application Partners, specifically
with all the major boiler manufacturers
who may include a fuel cell in their
appliances, and two of these companies
recently visited us in Melbourne.
corporatefile.com.au
The UK government is very supportive
of renewable energy. Are there any
prospects of winning UK government
support?
CEO Brendan Dow
Indeed the UK government earlier
this year cut the VAT specifically for micro-
CHP appliances from 17.5 percent
to 5 percent thereby making these units more
attractive. The UK government has
positive policies on fuel cell energy
generation and on energy efficient
appliances, such as condensing boilers and
micro-CHP systems.
The UK government has also established
project incentive programs for field
trials of fuel cells, renewable
fuel trials and more. We recently recruited a
specialist, Dr Alan Chapman, who
is based at our UK office, to access these
government funded initiatives and
we’ve already submitted several project
proposals for funding.
corporatefile.com.au
You have been CEO for the last four
weeks. What attracted you to Ceramic Fuel
Cells and how has your experience
of its operations and commercial prospects
compared with your expectations?
CEO Brendan Dow
I was initially attracted by the
challenge of commercialising a technology that is a
revolutionary change from centralised
to decentralised electricity generation.
There are several industries which
will affect the way we live in the future, but the
most important will be the ones
that are based on environmental sustainability.
Fuel cells and electrical energy
from fuel cells is one of those industries. For me
this presents a great personal opportunity
to make a difference.
Ceramic Fuel Cells is certainly one
of the leading players in the global fuel cell
industry. I really had no expectations
in terms of the operations, but it is fair to say
that the team at CFU has a very
good understanding of micro-CHP technology
and processes which places us in
a strong position to scale up to mass production.
During my recent visit to our European
subsidiary and meetings with potential
commercial partners I was certainly
pleased to see how advanced toward
commercialisation we are.
corporatefile.com.au
What strategic goals have you set
for Ceramic Fuel Cells?
CEO Brendan Dow
The company has already announced
some goals for the coming financial year,
including signing more contracts
for field trials, engaging with application
partners and continuing to improve
the design and performance of our fuel cells.
We’ll secure further funding and
list on the AIM market.
As you’d expect, like any new CEO
I’ll be reviewing the company’s current
strategy and business plan with
the Board and my management team, both in
Australia and Europe, but I don’t
expect any drastic changes as a result of that
process. Clearly, it’s important
for us to work closely with appliance
manufacturers who we believe in
the future will make units in larger volumes for
sale to the utilities and the retail
market.
We’ll also continue to do field trials
to demonstrate our prototype fuel cell
powered micro-CHP to showcase the
benefits of fuel cells as generators of
electricity. These field trials
are to prove our technology to relevant partners, both
appliance manufacturers and utilities.
corporatefile.com.au
Now that CFU is progressing to the
commercial prototype trial stage do you
consider the current business model
appropriate when your competitors are
subsidiaries of multinational industrial
corporations?
CEO Brendan Dow
It’s not strictly correct that all
of our competitors are subsidiaries of
multinationals, however our focus
gives us a significant advantage over larger
more diverse players who may have
some conflicting priorities. If fuel cells are
only a sideline of a much bigger
business, it can be difficult to compete for
internal resources and support.
That’s not the case at CFU. As a single focus
organisation we can respond quickly
to the emerging market for fuel cells.
In fact, among our closest competitors
– that is, other companies developing small
solid oxide fuel cell products –
we are one of the few ‘pure play’ listed companies
that are currently focused on that
market segment. Other companies targeting that
space are also chasing other opportunities
– either different types of fuel cells or
different product sizes, or the
fuel cell operations of some of those companies are
only a very small part of their
overall business. We believe we give our
shareholders an opportunity to invest
in fuel cells without the ‘baggage’ of a huge
multinational business.
Furthermore, because we do all our
own design, development, testing and
construction in-house we have a
thorough understanding and control of all
components in the fabrication and
operation of our fuel cells and the balance of
plant, that is the control systems.
Some other companies, even those that are large
multinationals, subcontract out
production of their fuel cell components, which we
believe can make it more difficult
to maintain quality control.
corporatefile.com.au
There has already been a change
in the senior level reporting structure within the
company with the CEO of Ceramic
Fuel Cells (Europe) now reporting to you as
CEO. What other changes are proposed
and what will this mean for the
operations of the company?
CEO Brendan Dow
Initially, when the European subsidiary
was set up, the CEO of CFU Europe,
Brendan Bilton, reported to the
Executive Chairman. The logical progression now
that I’m CEO of the group is for
Brendan to report to me.
I do not have any significant senior
reporting structural changes to make
immediately - most changes will
revolve around ensuring our structure internally
can most efficiently deliver the
strategy at the lowest possible cost.
corporatefile.com.au
You are currently building another
two CHP units for trials in Victoria and New
Zealand. How will you fund the additional
units for EWE?
CEO Brendan Dow
The additional units for our field
trials, including with EWE, are being assembled
now. The commercial terms of the
EWE deal are confidential, however EWE has
made a significant contribution
towards the cost of the units.
corporatefile.com.au
Your reported R&D expenditure
was $5.6 million for the half year to December
2004. Will R&D expenditure fall
now that you have overcome the technical
hurdles to get the first prototype
into the market?
CEO Brendan Dow
The R&D team has turned its
focus to making our fuel cells more powerful and
cost effective with longer life;
all this and the integration into appliances has to be
achieved in a tight timeframe. Therefore,
I’m not sure it’s correct to say that our
R&D costs will fall significantly
in absolute terms. Certainly they have fallen as a
percentage of total costs, as our
focus shifts towards commercialising our
technology. For instance, in FY03
R&D costs were 71 percent of our total
expenses, and for FY04 they were
64 percent, and they’re likely to stay at around
the 60 percent level, at least in
the short term.
corporatefile.com.au
Thank you Brendan
__________________________________________________________________
For further information on Ceramic
Fuel Cells please visit www.cfcl.com.au
or
call Helen Millicer (Investor and
Public Relations Manager) on +61 3 9554 2300
or +61 (0) 413 875 872.
|
|